PC Boards, My Way
Mar 5, 2012 Electronic Projects
I have found a new way of making PC boards.
I start with a bare board.
Place a thin layer of “secret” resistant coating on it.(on a spin coater)
Use my CNC router to “engrave” it with a drag scribe.
With out moving it, drill it and route outline.
Last etch it in ferric chloride.
Now this may seem odd at first. Why not just route the board with the CNC?
Let me try to explain. I have always used the photo resist method with laser transparencies and pre-sensitized boards, etched then drilled. When all goes well, the results are great. The biggest problem has always been getting a good 1 to 1 print from the laser printer. Next problem is lining the board up to drill it, which gets worse if the print was not square or to scale to begin with.
Now, my main reason is I am sorta cheep. I have never bought the right bits to do direct PCB routing. My router does pretty good, but I am just not sure how it would do, and hate to spend money just to break bits. I like the photo method, but bare boards are cheaper. There is also the fact I already have a bubble tank of etchant.
When I first started experimenting with my method I used an old photo board I had. It was a bit old, so I just tossed it in developer with out exposing it to fix the resist first. This worked, but still expensive board and the coating is very fragile and gets scratched during drilling. More on the coating later.
Next I made a drag engraving point out of an old carbide bit. I tried various angles and about 90 deg. works well. I mounted the point in a solid tool holder off to the side of my spindle, which is just a Rotozip, and while still fairly tight, does have a bit of play. Since I would be dragging and not spinning the bit I saw no reason to put the strain on the bearings or risk unnecessary flexing error. The bit holder is also longer than the spindle so I can leave my drill bit in and install and remove the holder between steps. (I have the offset set in EMC2)
I mount the board on a piece of “foam core” sign board with double face tape like used on window film. It is very thin and very sticky. This is then stuck to my table. This gives me a well supported board with the foam core having just a bit of give and acts as a waste board underneath for drilling.
I then run my code for the trace outlines. I use Kicad with pcb2gcode, but have came up with some scripts I will get into in another post* for generating my files and getting good results. I also incorporate a modified version of Etch_Z_Adjust to keep my depth consistent. I replace my scribe with a touch probe made from a micro switch and probe the surface first. I then replace the scribe and use a depth of .0015″ which scores though my coating and leaves a fine line in the copper.
Now I remove the scribe and reset for drilling. Since nothing has been moved, everything is already lined up.
Last I do any cutout routing I want for the board shape.
Once finished on the CNC it is into the ferric chloride . Here one of the complaints often heard about FeCl is actually put to use. The scribe lines are very fine, but since I lightly scored the copper, a small amount of undercutting occurs, widening the lines slightly.
Does it save me any time? Well, I have ran 1.5″ X 6″ boards with 162 holes that take less than 10 minutes to engrave at 20 in/min. Compare with 8~12 min. exposure time and then developing, that is not bad when I do not have to realign for drilling. Etching is also quicker since I am not removing as much copper. Doing multiple boards takes longer of course, but if I make a mistake, only one gets screwed up and not a whole panel. I can also run different boards at the same time without having to make new films.
Once I was able to get good results, I wanted to stop using pre-sensitized boards and started looking for a coating that would work. I also needed a way to apply it consistently. I tried spray paint. Worked, but not consistent and had to be removed at the end. Tried various clear coats, polyurethane, stains, and wax with mixed results. One big problem was even coating without bubbles or dust. (like most people, I don’t work in a “clean” room!)
The “secret” coating I found: Future vinyl floor finish! (now sold under the Pledge with Future name)
Apparently, model builders have been using it for years to coat windshields and protect decals. It is tough! Dries FAST. Nontoxic. And last, CHEEP! I add a little food coloring to make it easier to see, and a bit of alcohol to thin it just a bit. Oh, and you can easily clean it up with an ammonia based window cleaner!
Now to get it on the board. I built a spin coater. A motor and a spinning disk. My first small attempts I used a muffin fan with a pot to control the speed and got good results. I up sized and can now handle a 6″ X 9″ board inside a bucket to contain the mess. I control the speed using EMC2 and a spare high current output on my CNC’s BOB. I came up with some custom M codes and a HAL file that let me control it like a spindle using PCM and can set the acceleration. I can now write a program to start slow while I apply the coating, spin up gently to throw off the excess, slow down to let it level and start to set, then spin the hell out of it and hit it with a heat gun to dry. The process is very quick and in less that 5 minutes I have a dry board ready to go, hardly enough time for dust to even settle on it if it could.
Added benefit, when the board is done, the coating is so thin it can be soldered though without removing it first and it protects the rest of the traces from corrosion.
*I will be doing another post on the scripts I use once I clean them up a bit.
*I will also be adding pictures the next time I run boards. I wanted to get this written up while I had a chance.
Tags: electronics, pc boards
